Login/Sign Up




Should nation states have nuclear arsenals?
Technology

welcome2hell
Dec 22, 2010
9 votes
4 debaters
1


+ Add Argument

4
Yes, they should.


pgandal
Dec 22, 2010
0 convinced
Rebuttal
Well seeing at it isn't possible for nuclear technology to wink out of existence, there might (might) be a positive side to responsible, treaty-bound governments possessing some nuclear weapons.

 
tnstepdad
Dec 22, 2010
0 convinced
Rebuttal
first, we need to define what exactly is a nation-state. In the latter part of the 20th century, the definition got somewhat muddled with the formation of organizations like OPEC and the European Union. Most often a nation state has been defined as a geographic area sharing ideological commonalities and economic interests. The internet and the resulting global economy has made this a bit more complicated. If we simplified it to nations with clearly defined geography and physical borders, then we might be onto something. While the cold war was a frightening time for many who lived in it, I think the current age is far more frightening.

Youd have to agree that the Soviets were nothing if not predictable, and the arsenals kept by the super powers resulted in a somewhat stable relationship..mutually assured destruction. The players in the game today are far less predictable and as we can see since 9/11, the world is far less stable.

Perhaps if the nations of the world all had a few nuclear weapons, we could return to that state of mutually assured destruction and restabilize the world.



 
+ Add Argument

5
No, they shouldn't


1broncofan
Dec 23, 2010
1 convinced
Rebuttal
Rebuttal to: pgandal Show

I know you said "might", but I'm positive that the posession of nuclear weapons are for one purpose, weapons. All I can see these weapons can be used for are war so I have to say that if it was possible, I would hope the weapons "vanish".

 
joryrferrell
Jan 17, 2011
0 convinced
Rebuttal
Rebuttal to: tnstepdad Show

Uhm, what about the people prepared to use the weapons regardless of mutual destruction.....those assholes do exist...

 


Use these tags to find similiar debates

technology apple BBC british Browser cell cell phone censorship CMM CMMI community computer computers Convince convinceme debate design digg education Facebook Firefox Frankie google ie Internet internet censorhip iPhone ISO15504 it java linux Mac Maturity Models Me microsoft military myspace Online Opera osx PC programming science search social space SPICE tech technology twitter uk VANCAM vista web website Wikipedia Windows world