Login/Sign Up




allow polyandry for wife with HIV postive husband
Conspiracy

Rizka Nurul Atika
Apr 27, 2012
5 votes
4 debaters
2
1


+ Add Argument

1
allow


Prasetyo Anzery
Apr 28, 2012
0 convinced
Rebuttal
i'm from positive team it should be, because husband who's already infected HIV, couldnt having a sex anymore with her husband, it means that Wife cannot have a child, so We as the affirmative provide to wife to get another Husband,


Tq
Jerry Anzery

 
Prasetyo Anzery
May 06, 2012
0 convinced
Rebuttal
Rebuttal to: Nesia Riyana Afri Show

It's like you do not understand what the purpose of this motion, here the problem is the wife not know that her husband ill with HIV or not, so here her husband has been sick and this motion came out the situation has not affected his wife, idea it easy which no a wife who want sex with her ??husband, who was known to a HIV positive, so she knows that her husband was HIV infected and certainly not his wife. So for the sake of the survival of the wife he had married another man because sooner or later the husband could not spend anymore because her condition had deteriorated.



Tq
Jerry Anzery

 
Prasetyo Anzery
Nov 09, 2014
0 convinced
Rebuttal
This is a misunderstanding , i had been very emotional due to seen statements like that and also tio is still new in the world of debate . for seniors please be advised . apologize profusely . glad to have been able to remove the argument. thank you

 
+ Add Argument

4
don't allow


Nesia Riyana Afri
Apr 28, 2012
2 convinced
Rebuttal
Yes you're right if husband is has been infected by HIV cannot having sexual intercourse !! but, by allowing the wife to polygamy it just kind of way to spread the disease that she got from her husben that has been infected by HIV, moreover we provide you a solution if the wife is willing to have children !! ADOPTION !!

Thank you
Nesia Riyana

 
Deemar Ya Marjan
May 03, 2012
1 convinced
Rebuttal
Rebuttal to: Prasetyo Anzery Show

Allowing the wife leaves his sick husband is morally wrong. It absolutely eliminate the mean of love itself. Remember what every brides say in the wedding day. they promise to be united forever after. Only dead would separate them. But only because of the possible infection of HIV - AIDS during sexual intercourse which is yet preventable, they betray the holy promise. A promise that never be made to be betrayed. a promise that bounds two different individual into one holy relationship which Family. A relation that would continue the human creature. This illness doesn't solely disturb sexual activity indeed. Simply by using condom you would be 100% free from the infection. If we allow this reason, we would see many diabetes husbands or wives divorcee. Because this disease indeed disturbs the sexual intercourse quality. moreover that is the moment the husband really needs support from as many as possible people in his life. He needs the support from children, wife, parents, friends and etc. the attention from those people would give him a spirit and courage to survive again the disease. Especially the wife.This psychological affection in many cases proven is as significantly important as the medicine itself. The husband needs everyone they love beside them. Seeing his lovely wife hugging, kissing and living with other man would rip his heart into pieces.
Firmly , if we do this it means we only love our couple when they are good, healthy and wealthy. When they are not, we leave them. do we still call ourselves human being ?

 
Rizka Nurul Atika
May 06, 2012
0 convinced
Rebuttal
Rebuttal to: Prasetyo Anzery Show

please be polite here, brother.
no personal attack here.

 
Deemar Ya Marjan
May 08, 2012
0 convinced
Rebuttal
Rebuttal to: Prasetyo Anzery Show

ou iya lah bang....

aku stupid.

hebat mulut mu sekarang ya.



 
Nesia Riyana Afri
May 13, 2012
0 convinced
Rebuttal
Rebuttal to: Prasetyo Anzery Show

That's Rude boy! we are now debating with rules, and you're not use your eyes before posted, "Remember to follow the rules, keep it clean" you're not as much as Immature debater. well, the case is wife with positive HIV husband. this case comes up when the husband knows he is Having the disease after he and his wife getting married! that's why we cannot let her wife getting married again ! there must be a symptom that has been spread to her wife! and imagine if we let them doing polyandry, she will spread the disease, and even when she is pregnant, the baby also contaminated with that dangerous disease. even more this disease untreated yet, so its much better we are not allowing them to have polyandry ! Keep your mouth on the track!

 


Use these tags to find similiar debates

2012 9/11 aliens bush Conspiracy Government JFK politics religion VanCam