Login/Sign Up




Doctors are more important that Teachers
Books

romaro
1 - 3
themind
21 - 3


3
Doctors are more important


romaro
Jul 30, 2008
Case #1
Doctors are much more important than Teachers because
1) Their role is to save peoples lives
2) Threat People for their diseases
3) Give advice to patients
Teachers are person who give the instruction, they don't carry out the task, just like how the software tells the computer what to do and the computer performs the task it the same thing in this case, the teachers give the instruction and the doctors perform the task.
OK take this example AIDS, teachers teaches about it, yes! they do but who is the one trying to find the cure for it, its that student and the student is the doctor. How can it be logical for a teachers trying to find out the cure for a disease, yes its important to know about the disease but it is even more important to try to find a vaccine to cure a prevent it and that the role of a doctor.
A disease is an abnormal condition of an organism that impairs bodily functions.
In human beings,"disease" is often used more broadly to refer to any condition that causes extreme pain, dysfunction, distress, social problems, and/or death to the person afflicted, or similar problems for those in contact with the person.
Oh forgetting something teachers would not have experience with some type of sickness or diseases because they aren't the one experimenting on it and interacting with them daily.
What Doctors do are far more important than what teachers do.
Doctors save life
Teachers teaches.
I did mention that doctors give advice, because the doctors has so much experience on that particular job, he can inform a teacher what to do and what not to do when she is pregnant or he has Cancer



 
romaro
Jul 30, 2008
Case #2
Yes! I have already pointed out that the teachers are the one who gives the instruction but does not perform the task.
The teacher will tell you what to do in a surgery but they are not the one who carry out the surgery
Action Speaks louder than words, word cannot save life and action does and the action is done by carry out a surgery operation on a patient.

 
romaro
Jul 31, 2008
Case #3
My opponent will argue that the teachers are the who has to tell you what to do and when to do it buts that's not true... When a teachers teaches you to do something, the purpose is for you to be a Pro in what ever, so you can be better that them.
When a teachers teaches about the brain, its not he or she job to study more on it.. its yours, because at the end of the year and you will be siting the EOY exams, he or she wont be there to tell you the answers, because it was your duty to study a know more about it
When a medical teacher teaches about the lungs, it is not his responsibility to be over you telling you what to do when your operating on a sick patients lungs to save his or her life

 
romaro
Aug 04, 2008
Case #4
Hello! you mentioned about cats a have teacher and they don't have doctors, tell you what you are wrong, cats have teachers and doctor, their mothers are the doctor, who feeds them, who takes care of them. Cats are no where to compare to our intelligence.
It was better if you use a dog instead

 
10
Teachers are more important.


themind
Jul 30, 2008
Case #1
Without teachers to teach the doctors, there would be no doctors. It follows that teachers are more important because they garner everything a doctor does, plus all the great benefits of passing on information (that would otherwise disappear) to the next generation.

Without someone to teach, we would still be living in caves, assuming each individual figured it out on his own that caves stop the rain from dropping on you.

 
themind
Jul 30, 2008
Case #2
Or, as Braincube put it in the open debate I just found:

"Who's gonna teach the doctors?"

Forsooth.

 
themind
Jul 30, 2008
Case #3
There will be no doctors without any teachers.

I understand your point: Teachers give instruction but do not perform the tasks themselves. Unfortunately, it is absolutely wrong.

I was taught to fire a 12-gauge shotgun at Scout Camp. The instructor did not say 'ok, so point that thing at the air and pull the trigger.' NO, He demonstrated his instruction. In other words, he performed the task, and in so doing, he taught me to shoot.

My brother-in-law is an anatomist. He instructs people who will become doctors. During his teaching, he demonstrates how to make certain incisions, what goes where and so on. In other words, He performs the task in order to teach his craft.

When I was taught to speak, my parents demonstrated language by using it. They did not leave me to discover language on my own. They performed the task an thereby I learned language.

Your main contention is that teachers do not do. It is wrong. The best teachers have done and will do.

Oh, and...words can and do save lives. More in my next post.

 
themind
Jul 30, 2008
Case #4
My opponent claims that actions are required to save lives. I propose that uninformed action does more harm than good. Without teachers, doctors would not know the aorta from the anus. Let's say you go in for an aortic bypass, and you leave with a second passage for poop to escape. The doctors acted, but their action was uninformed by a teacher.

Words, and the transmission of ideas through them, have saved an infinitely larger amount of human lives than doctors could ever dream of.

 
themind
Jul 31, 2008
Case #5
In response to my opponents post number three:

Not at all. No teacher will give you everything on a silver platter. That is not teaching. A teacher will instruct you on method, true, but the individual has as much responsibility to learn as the teacher has to teach.

Let's look at it this way: If we had no doctors we would still have teachers. If we had no teachers, we would have no doctors.

Or another way: without the ability to pass on information from one generation to the next, technological advances would be impossible.

Humanity will survive without doctors. It has for aeons. Humanity will implode without teachers.

Even animals have teachers. Barn cats learn to hunt from their mothers. They have no doctors. They are doing fine, except for the whole having to eat mice thing.

Think about it: Teachers are integral to every facet of who we are. We learn language, math, science, biology, communication, food preparation, mobility, everything from someone. Without teachers, humans are pet-food. Savvy?

 


Use these tags to find similiar debates

angmar battle of riddle tom vs. witchking . 10 2008 50 9/11 911 is it real or not A a hard days night Abortion adsf adult afganistan age Agent Agent Gibbs aliens alternative energy America American amnesty anarchism Ancient warfare animal rights Animal Welfare Act Animals another anthropogenic ANWR Any battle (not a war). anything Arab Arabs arms arms and the man Army Authority AWA awesome Ayn Rand bad bag banned bar Barack Batman be bear beatles beer Beer Wine bella Beneficial Best better bible Bilbo book Books Bush California Capitalism Captain Jack Sparrow Captain Jack Sparrow VS Agent Gibbs carbon cars Catholic Church Catholisism change Chinese choice Christ christianity Christianty Church Civil climate CO2 comedy Comics Conflict conscription conspiracy Convinceme.net country Creation cruel culture cyber cyberpunk darwin DC debate Defy deport Design dozens drilling Drive driving drug war drugs Dumb*ss dumbledore dysgenics ebooks economics edward eminem employment end of the world Ender endit Energy English environment ethical ethics eugenics Evil evolution experience Fairness doctrine fantasy Fast Fatah fiction fight force foreign oil forever Frankie Franks free speech freedom Fuel funny game gandalf Gasoline Gay Marriage genetics george harrison Gibbs global Global Warming Global Warming Humans Caused it cause climate change God God Works and Faith are Needed in Salvation in the Last Judgement good goofy government Green Guns Hamas hardback Harry Potter Hate Hawthorne Healthcare Hebrew hegemony heroes Hillary hip hop history homo House house buying hunt hunting idealism illegals immigrants impeach Intelligent Design International realations Iran iraq iraq war peace democrat republican Islam Israel issue it's iunno J Jack Sparrow jesus Jew Jewish Jews JFK JK Rowling john lennon JRR Judaism kaka KFC kids KKK kobe Koran LA language last.fm law Laws lebron Legal lexicon license live feedings logical long lose Love Machinima magic magic. mandatory Marijuana Marijuana Legalized 50 states Marines Marvel Medicine Mental microsoft Middle East military minimum Misleading money mongoloids Moral Dilema morality morals movie movies music Muslim Myspace nations natural NCIS never ninjas nitpick no no difference noisy neighbors Novel NWA obama obesity Objectivism of Of Mice and Men Oil opponent Opponent's opponent's choice Opponents Choice opposite or overweight Palestine Palestinian Palestinians Pandora paperback PAS paul mccartney permit PETA philosophy physician pirates play Police politics pop Power powerpoint President pride Primitivism Prop 8 Pull Out punk Qu'ran R R.C. Race